Treasure Island Homes for Sale

Included below are homes for sale in Treasure Island. If you would like more information on any of these Treasure Island homes real estate listings, just click the "Request More Information" button when viewing the details of that property. We can provide you with disclosures, past sales history, dates and prices of homes recently sold nearby, and more.

And, if you haven't already, be sure to register for a free account so that you can receive email alerts whenever new Treasure Island Home listings come on the market.

Treasure Island Homes April 24, 2024
Avg. DOM
Avg. $ / Sq.Ft.
Med. List Price
73 Properties
Page 1 of 7

More on Treasure Island Florida

Treasure Island Homes for SaleTreasure Island, as luxuriously fanciful as it sounds is actually a barrier island in Pinellas County Florida. It got its name in the early 20th century after several property owners attempted to boost sales of homes being developed on the island by first burying a few wooden chests around the island and then pretending to discover them around 1915. After claiming the chests were filled with treasure, the news of the discovery quickly spread and folks started calling the island Treasure Islands. The island itself is only 3 feet in elevation and in 1848, a large storm carved out John's Pass on the island's north end and split off to smaller islands called the Isle of Palms and the Isle of Capri. In the 1950s, treasure Island had a huge surge in residential and hotel construction and today is filled with condominium buildings, complexes, single-family homes, and a thriving restaurant scene in downtown. Legendary baseball slugger Babe Ruth even had a winter beachfront home on Treasure Island after his retirement.

Why Choose Treasure Island?

Treasure Island makes a beautiful place to call home either permanently, seasonally, or as a vacation destination. It's nestled between John's Pass and St. Pete Beach and encompasses the small islands of Isle of Capri, Isle of Palms and Paradise Island, which is home to the Treasure Island Causeway heading over to St. Petersburg. Toward the north end of the island are residential homes that sit right on the beach but between 119th Ave. and 104th Ave., you'll find hotels and resorts along the beach. There are residential homes that lined the bay as well and also the three main islands that are part of Treasure Island are all residential. Nearly every home is waterfront with boat docks and access to the Gulf of Mexico through John's Pass.

Treasure IslandIf you're looking to relax, chill out, and enjoy retirement, your vacation home, or just the beach, Treasure Island is the place to do it. It's primarily a resort town with a few restaurants and a couple of markets. However, St. Pete Beach is a couple of minutes south and St. Petersburg is just 20 minutes East along 1st Ave., North. Major shops, restaurants, markets and other services and amenities are no more than about 5 to 20 minutes from the majority of residential homes on Treasure Island. But if you're looking to escape at all, this is the place to do it.

Things to Do on Treasure Island

While this is a relaxation destination, you will find a lot of touristy events and things to do but you will find some of the best drinks along the beach, relaxing resorts, and fantastic fishing. You can parasail the pass toward the north end of the island, rent a boat or charter a fishing vessel, or simply enjoy Kingfish Park. The John Morroni Memorial Dog Park is located on the Isle of Capri right next to Rosselli Park. This local park features tennis courts, sports fields, and a great dog park as well as a trail that circles the park itself.


There are great restaurants all up and down Treasure Island such as Caddy's Treasure Island located right on the beach. This funky Florida hang-out offers great waterfront dining with cabana rentals, catering events, and delicious food and drinks.

Sea Dog Brewing Company located right along Highway 699 is your spot for some of the best craft beers in Pinellas County. With the gulf-inspired menu, merchandise, billiards table, open-air seating, live entertainment, and delicious brews, it's a great place to hang out with your buddies on the weekend.

Rick's Tiki Bar is a favorite for vacationers and locals alike. Located right on the beach, you'll find a casual yet cozy outdoor seating restaurant serving up delicious cocktails and you can even bring your own outside food if you have a favorite.

Other great restaurants include Ricky T's Bar and Grille, CJ's on the Island, Sloppy Joe's on the Beach, R Bar, Middle Grounds Grill, and the traditional Waffle House. And, to finish it all up, you'll have to check out Shake Shop for some delicious malts, milkshakes, and ice cream.

Treasure Island Homes for Sale

Beachfront condominiums start at about $700,000 with single-family homes on the Isle of Capri and the Isle of Palms ranging from a $350,000 to $1.5 million. Nearly every home has waterfront access, views, and a boat dock. Homes were built from the 1950s to today and older homes have seen some tear downs and re-builds into more modern or luxurious styles. Many homes have a one or two-car garage and if you're looking to build your own custom home, chances are you'll need to find a home that is ready for demolition in order to rebuild as there are no available lots on Treasure Island.

For more information on homes for sale on Treasure Island Florida, browse available listings on our website or contact my office at any time to schedule a showing.

Contact Treasure Island Home Realtor®

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Images by dconvertini  Michel Curi